Skip to main content

A $300 Oil Change For Your Car?

I was a guest this month on Hot Shopping Tips (episode 14) – a series of free and really helpful podcasts by my friends and former Consumer Reports colleagues Lisa Lee Freeman and Mandy Walker. The subject was: "Ten hacks to get the best deals on cars and avoid repair ripoffs." I thought I'd provide some additional specifics in a few posts here. Today: How to save hundreds on vehicle scheduled maintenance.

If you check your car's owner's or maintenance manual, you'll find the car maker's recommended maintenance schedules.

For instance, there may a list of maintenance procedures at 5,000 miles or six months and another at 10,000 miles or 12 months.

It's  important to take care of your car or truck as the manufacturer recommends, especially if you don't want to risk the warranty coverage. But just telling a car dealer or independent mechanic that it's time for scheduled maintenance is a surefire way to end up with an unnecessarily big bill.

Maintenance schedules typically include many items that you easily do yourself, such as checking the installation of the driver's floor mat, topping off the antifreeze and other fluids and inspecting the wiper blades. Indeed, there's usually a bunch of things to check that a  shop would be happy to look at for free After all, it's prospecting for work for which may be able to charge you.

Consider the 36,000-mile/36-month maintenance schedule I examined for a 2016 Toyota Highlander in preparation for Lisa and Mandy's podcast. Other than a lot of stuff to inspect, there's very little to do. Essentially it's changing the engine oil and oil filter, replacing the cabin and engine air filters and rotating the tires.

Yet, for 30,000 maintenance on a 2016 Highlander, the auto repair website RepairPal estimated the cost at $469 to $628 – and for just six of the items on the list of recommended procedures. A local Toyota dealer gave me a much lower quote, around $300. A big price for what amounts to little more than an oil change.

For comparison, I priced the important procedures piecemeal, instead as part of a scheduled maintenance package.

For the oil change, a local tire chain had a $29 special, including the use of synthetic blend oil. It said it would rotate the tires for free. I found the engine and cabin air filters at an auto parts store for $20. You can change them both yourself in just a few minutes. There are plenty of videos online that show you how.

Next, I called back the same Toyota dealer to ask about doing a multi-check to see if the vehicle needed any additional work. This time I didn't mention anything about $30,000-mile service. As I expected, the dealer offered to look over vehicle or free.

The bottom line?  Bottom line? That $300 scheduled maintenance would now cost about $50. For an all-wheel-drive Highlander, figure on adding another $25 to $40 for some recommended driveshaft maintenance, which neither the dealer nor RepairPal mentioned in their list of items.

What to Do

Never tell a repair shop that your vehicle needs scheduled maintenance, or you'll likely trigger an estimated for a high-priced package of services. Instead, review the list of maintenance recommendation and decide what really needs to be done and what simple items you can do yourself. If you're not sure, ask a friend or relative who knows something about cars. Keep in mind that with a simple web search, you likely can find a lot of free  online videos that explain how to simple maintenance on your vehicle, whether it's inspecting fluids, changing filters or anything else on that list.

For procedures for which you need or want to hire a pro, gets estimates for those items alone. Comparison shop. By law, you're not required to have an authorized dealer perform the recommended maintenance as a condition to maintaining the manufacturer's warranty (although warranty coverage could be affected if maintenance is done incorrectly.

One related tip: Be cautious if a repair shop recommends maintenance that isn't on the manufacturer's list of recommended procedures, such as flushing your transmission or filling your tires with nitrogen. These services typically have little or no benefit and are intended to increase the shop's profits. Occasionally, car makers do add items to the list of recommended maintenance based on issues they discover as models age. If the shop says that's the case with your vehicle, make it show you a car maker's so-called technical service bulletin  or other proof, or verify with the car maker directly.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Use Caution With Free Trial Offers

T he Federal Trade Commission has issued yet another warning about free trial offers that can end up costing you money. The agency announced on Wednesday  that the U.S. district court in California has granted its request to temporarily shut down an alleged internet marketing scam that promoted bogus free trial offers. The case underscores why you need to be careful about enrolling in free trials while shopping for the holidays or any other time. And even "legitimate" free trials can leave you with unexpected charges.    Consumers bilked for tens of millions of dollars In the case announced Wednesday, the FTC accused numerous U.S. and United Kingdom-based companies and individuals with charging customers full price in connection with free-trial offers for more than 50 dietary supplements and personal care items. The products were marketed as  promoting  weight loss, hair growth, clear skin, muscle development, sexual performance and  cognitive abilities, the agency said

Why It's a Bad Idea to Maintain Emergency Savings If You Have Credit Card Debt

A  new Bankrate survey that examines how much people have in credit card debt compared to emergency savings raises in interesting question: How much should you keep in an emergency fund if you also owe money on your credit cards? My answer is: very little, if anything. The Bankrate survey of 1,004 consumers revealed that three in every 10 Americans have more credit card debt than emergency savings.  Of course, having any credit card debt is reason to worry. And too many people are living paycheck to paycheck, a problem underscored by the recent federal shutdown . But what if the survey found the opposite, that people have more in savings than credit card debt? That's actually worse because it would mean that they are keeping money in savings accounts earning, say, just 2.5 percent while paying double-digit interest on their credit card debt. That makes no sense. Think of it this way: Would you borrow money at, say, 22 percent interest so you can put it in the bank at

Consumer Fraud: The Storm After the Hurricane

A s the South endures the effects of hurricane Florence (now a tropical storm), warnings already are being issued about another storm that's expected to follow, this one entirely man-made: Consumer fraud. Even as Florence was approaching the mainland, alerts sent out about post-storm scams, including this warning from the Better Business Bureau. There are at least three types of disaster-related fraud you should know about, even if you don't live in an area directly affected by the storm: Charity and home contractor scams and the sale of flood and other storm-damaged cars to unsuspecting motorists. Here's how these types of fraud work and what you can do to avoid them. Charity scams During my more than 30 years as a consumer and finance journalist, I've seen many examples of scammers trying to take advantage of the generosity of people who want to help those affected by hurricanes and other disasters. The fraud could be perpetrated using a website for a b